Catfish Hotel’s Lemon Rub Pie
Hagy’s Catfish Hotel has been serving fish on the banks of the Tennessee River since the early 1930’s at the site next to Shiloh Battlefield where the Hagy family landed and laid claim to several acres of bottom land in 1825. MamMaw Hagy added this dessert to the menu in the late 1930’s. Prepared using only the freshest ingredients, this sweet and tangy pie is the perfect ending to a hearty Southern style catfish dinner. When the Delta Queen steamboat traveled up the Tennessee River, the ship’s chef would call one day before the boat docked at the Shiloh battlefield and order 25 Lemon Rub Pies to go. The cooks would squeeze lemons and bake through the night to insure the pies were ready when the boat landed.
1 9-inch unbaked pie shell
1-3/4 cups sugar
1 tablespoon self rising flour
1 tablespoon self rising corn meal
4 eggs
1/4 cup melted butter (measure after melted)
1/4 cup milk
2 tablespoons grated lemon rind
1/4 cup lemon juice
Preheat oven to 375 degrees. Combine sugar, flour and corn meal. Add eggs, melted butter, milk, lemon rind and lemon juice. Beat until blended. Pour into unbaked shell. Bake 35 – 40 minutes until top is golden brown.
For more Tablescape Thursdays visit
For more Foodie Friday visit http://designsbygollum.blogspot.com
For more Food on Friday visit http://annkroeker.wordpress.com/
For more Recipe Swaps visit http://grocerycartchallenge.blogspot.com/
For more Fight Back Friday visit http://www.foodrenegade.com


18 comments:
Your table is lovely. This pie is very similar to one called lemon chess pie in Southside Virginia where I grew up. We use plain flour and white unbolted corn meal instead of self rising, but I am going to try it your way next time. For holidays, I often make the recipe in small tart pans for part of a dessert buffet. Yum!
Looks delish! Can't wait to try it out this spring - what a great way to usher in a new season!
What lovely dishes and the pie looks great too. I loved the history behind the pie! Thanks. Joni
Your pie looks great, I copied the recipe and plan to cook it soon. I love lemon pie and this sounds great. I'll let you know how mine turns out.
Smiles, Pat
Lemon pie is so yummy. The name got my attention. Thanks for sharing the story and I want to make this recipe soon. Our son and family lived in Tenn for 4 years of grad school and loved it! ~♥
It does sound like lemon chess pie - love that pie. Thanks for sharing the recipe.
The delicate yellow china sets the stage for the lemon pie. Libby, this is gorgeous!
libby, have lived in tn for 61 years, and eaten at shiloh but have never heard this story, that is so neat....will try this pie very soon....love your tablescape..china is gorgeous.....i am enjoying your blog so much!!!! jennie <><
I am such a fan of lemon pie. This sounds like a recipe I will have to try. I like the interesting history of the recipe too.
I have never heard of this pie before... with cornmeal in it! Lovely table, Libby!
Hi, Libby...boy, I've missed you!! Hope all is good in your world.
This beautiful pie, served on that beautiful setting is magnificent. Sounds like a delightful pie, too. Never have used cornmeal in a pie, but....I'm game.
hugs, bj
Libby, this is most likely going to be another FrenchGardenHouse favorite! Sounds delicious, and what a great story, too. Hope you have a happy and fun filled weekend, xo Lidy
This will be perfect to serve with the chicken recipe from 1836 that I posted last week. I love vintage everything, including recipes!
Dang, Libby, you sure know how to put together an amazing tablescape!
Libby- You are amazing! Our family used to LOVE to go to the Catfish Hotel for dinner and I do remember the pie. Thanks for the recipe and the story. Their hushpuppies were the best, too!
Anxiously awaiting Spring and browzing through your site .. saw the picture/story of the pie! A neat way to welcome Spring! I will be trying it!! Thank you for enticing me to get to the kitchen and do something!
Love your site!
Pink Hugs,
Dee
Oh my, I stop in a for a visit and find the delicious buttermilk pie, the pork roast and now this tempting lemon pie. Delish! I'm up late and now I'm starving!
it is so good to see this buttermilk pie, I think I want to get this incredible pie, it is an special dessert that everyone deserves.
Post a Comment